Follow Up Thoughts on ClassDojo Terms of Service
19 min read
Update, 08 October 2015: Since this post was written, I have had the opportunity to talk with people within ClassDojo. In these conversations, we candidly discussed the issues raised in this post. The team within ClassDojo listened, and incorporated this feedback while they updated their policies. In short, they were responsive to constructive criticism, and improved their terms. I would love to see other companies follow their example. End update
A couple weeks back, I put out a post on the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy of ClassDojo. For background context to this post, please read the comment thread in response to the original. One of the commenters was Sam Chaudhary, the co-founder of ClassDojo. He made some excellent points in his comment, and I wanted to be sure to respond. Toward that end, and toward not having the dialogue get lost in the comment threads, I pulled this response into a new post. Sam's comments are included as quoted text, and my responses follow.
Bill, hey! This is Sam, co-founder of ClassDojo. Thank you for such a thoughtful post and some excellent feedback; I wanted to chime in with a few thoughts - all of us in education are trying to do the best we can for students, and that is good common ground to start from!
Hello, Sam - Thank you for contributing here. I appreciate you making the time, and your thoughtful feedback. I have some additional thoughts and questions, which I include inline below.
I’ve said this before publicly, but it’s worth being clear about it: ClassDojo does not now, and will never, sell or rent users’ personal information to anyone - especially marketers and advertisers. I was a teacher, and I feel strongly about this - so I insisted we state this clearly in our privacy policy: “we are not in the business of renting or selling your Personal Information or Children's Personal Information to anyoneâ€. We take a lot of pride in doing what’s right by our teachers, parents and students, and all our operating practices reflect our belief in doing just that.
I hear what you are saying here. If your policies stopped here, and didn't include additional language around partnerships, what you have in place here would be pretty solid. But, as I will discuss below, there are places where individual policy provisions appear to be contradictory, and your stated policies drift from your stated intent.
Your post makes some excellent points, very thoughtfully: in the same spirit, I wanted to clarify and provide more detail on how we’re thinking about or addressing these. For what it’s worth, it feels like we’re very aligned on a ‘user-centric’ approach to privacy in how we operate - and I totally agree that some of the ‘legalese’ in our terms / privacy policy could be clarified to reflect that approach.
Somewhere, somehow, there has to be a balance between the legalese and the human-readable version. Toward that end, I like the format used by 500px, with the terms in one column and a human readable summary dsiplayed alongside the terms.
1. Communicating about ‘specials’: the intention here was for ‘specials’ to mean one-off special features, materials, events or offers. An example would be, for example, the ‘back-to-school night’ guide (www.classdojo.com/backtoschoolnight) we recently created for teachers - it’s not a ‘new feature’, but is a special guide for a one-off event. I agree this could be clearer, so we will get this clarified!
If you specified that a "special" was just an event announcement, and differentiated that from any sales pitch related emails, that would help clarify the purpose here. This could also be augmented (or possibly even rendered unnecessary) if you allowed teachers to opt-in to specific types of announcements. Categories could include "Let me know about new features", "Let me know about offers from partners", etc. By making it opt-in and then clarifying the types of announcements you might send, you would make this more transparent. Then, this section could be modified to let teachers know that they can set these options in their account settings.
If this is already an option for teachers in their account settings, please ignore this. I created a demo teacher account, and did not see any options for controlling emails in the profile settings, but it's possible I missed it.
And, at the risk of stating the obvious, marketing to teachers students and parents shouldn't happen, and the terms should specify that here.
2. Students’ under 13 sharing information: to clarify: we do not allow students to share personal information with us (and we don’t ask for it, except for legal reasons - such as discovering that students are under 13 in the first place!), even after they have signed up.
This is one of those areas where the blind spots of COPPA become more apparent. If you have a class of second graders, you will be getting information about students under 13. This will largely be from teachers, so it will be information shared *about* U13s instead of information shared *by* them, which falls more outside of COPPA and under FERPA, provided the information shared is an educational record. But, given that the data stored on your site is arguably more of an observation than an educational record, it's not clear if FERPA even applies (and I'm not a lawyer, and would love to hear an informed legal opinion on this).
Having a policy of only using initials for last names for under 13s (arbitrarily determined by grade level of the class) would be a decent balance point. I think that clarifying the language around responding to COPPA issues, and clarifying exactly what "delete" means in all contexts would mitigate this.
And with that said, COPPA compliance is tricky. While schools are generally in the best spot to triage this, they are also more likely to not understand their obligations, which puts service providers in a tricky place. But both COPPA and FERPA are pretty out of date, which really doesn't help things.
3. Combining teacher information with other lists: when teachers join ClassDojo, they have the option of joining their school. Teachers are now able to easily collaborate with each other using ClassDojo, but in order to create this safe environment, we needed to ensure we had a list of real schools - and this sentence basically covers us matching the school a teacher enters with a list of all schools in the US. I agree the language sounds scary when it’s not intended to be - we will clarify this in the next update.
Your current language is pretty broad, and allows combining data from almost any source. If you are only going to combine teacher data against a school list, you should say that, but your current terms don't place many limits on data sources used in recombination. I'm glad to hear that you will be cleaning this language up, as your current policies allow behavior that is far more broad that your stated intent.
4. Others who may sell items / provide services to you with ClassDojo: if you use ClassDojo you’ll know that we don’t sell anything from third parties - and, as I’ve mentioned, we will never sell or rent information to advertisers to sell things to you. This sentence is merely intended to allow us to one day work with other parties to provide a more complete package of services to teachers, parents and students; an example would be giving teachers videos or guides on ‘how to build persistence’. We don’t do that currently, but if we ever did, as stated, we will not share personal information beyond what is necessary to provide those services, and we’ll make it abundantly clear when services are being offered with a partner, with clear options to opt-out. Again, the spirit is right but I agree the language can be clarified, and it appears there is a sentence conflict that should be resolved - we will update it in the next version.
This is where things really drift. Starting with the easy part: additional services should be opt-in, not opt-out. Your users should have the option to choose whether or not they find a new service valuable or not.
But where it gets very fuzzy is with this line: "We don’t do that currently, but if we ever did, as stated, we will not share personal information beyond what is necessary to provide those services" - earlier, you say that ClassDojo "will never, sell or rent users’ personal information to anyone". But, in this section, you describe a potential partnership where data would be transferred as needed to fulfill the needs of a business transaction. From the perspective of an end user, it doesn't really matter if their data is transferred as part of an outright sale, or if their data is transferred as a required element of a business arrangement: when the dust settles, their data has been shared with a third party.
My point here: what matters is that, under specific conditions, ClassDojo terms allow an unspecified portion of user data to be transferred to 3rd parties. Given that you describe an opt-out system, the data could be transferred without explicit user consent. Your terms should be explicit about that. The conflicting language ("we will never sell data to anyone" versus "we can share data as needed to facilitate partnerships") is confusing, and in the end doesn't prevent user data from being moved to a 3rd party.
5. Business transfers - I’m afraid in this case the interpretation might be a little off. This term does not refer to ‘selling on information’ whenever we want to as a business asset; it largely covers the case of ClassDojo ever being acquired, or going bankrupt, both of which are legal outcomes our lawyers need us to be explicit about. If either of those ever happens, again, we will continue to do right by our users: our position will continue to be to never sell on or rent information to marketers or advertisers in either of those cases, or do other sleazy things with user information. You are right that this could be misinterpreted, though - I will attempt to clarify this in the next iteration.
If ClassDojo specified that users would have a 30-60 day window to deactivate their account, and have all their data deleted before a sale or bankruptcy proceeding, this section would be much more user friendly. As it currently reads, user data becomes an asset that is included with the sale. While I hear you - loud and clear - that your intent is sound, your ability to control what happens to transferred data becomes pretty negligible in either a sale or a bankruptcy.
An improvement here would include these components:
a. Users will be notified in the case of a sale, and will have X days to export and/or delete their accounts and all associated data; b. Define the means by which users will be notified of a sale or bankruptcy; c. Define that the data that is transferred to a new owner will not include legacy backups that contain user data that might have otherwise been deleted.
6. Deleting information fully - I believe we’re on the same page here, but the wording may be confusing and I’d like to improve that. To clarify, we delete a user’s profile fully and completely from our databases when requested. Some remnant information may still exist - a good example being a student report downloaded by a parent, and of course we cannot delete something that has been downloaded! We’ll absolutely clarify this language, however, so that users are aware they can delete their account fully.
That's awesome. I'm assuming that the parent account has a "Delete My Account and My Child's Account" option? I don't know, because I haven't seen the parent UI, but making the account cancellation process as frictionless as possible is a user-friendly implementation. I did not see any mechanism for teachers to delete their account. I'm assuming that this is because there is more data associated with teacher accounts, and you are attempting to protect teachers from destructive data loss due to user error. But with that said, teachers could be protected against user error via confirmation/splash screens. It's 2014, and the UX of doing that well is not new ground.
What you say about downloads makes perfect sense :)
7. Deleting information fully for COPPA-compliance - as above, we delete information fully, so we’re on the same page here.
Awesome. Thanks for clarifying.
8. Updating terms - we make it clear that we will send you a notice via email or post notices on the website. I believe this is pretty common practice, but I’d love to hear other methods of making updates more explicit.
Big +1 on the email and notice approach. Combining this with an explicit acceptance of the new terms would be a great approach. The notice on the site and the email could both contain links for parents/teachers to review and accept the updated terms of service.
However, this is in direct contradiction to the language in the second line of your terms of service. The line reads, "By visiting the websites or using the services in any manner, you agree that you have read and agree to be bound by and a party to the terms and conditions of this agreement without modification to the exclusion of all other terms."
As this line reads, it appears to state that if anyone visits any page on the site, they implicitly agree to the terms. Given that this line is the second line of the terms of service, it's both absurd and confusing to make a claim that visiting a page constitutes agreement.
I suspect that what happened here is that your terms have evolved over several iterations, with specific sections being added without a comprehensive review of the entire document. This is not abnormal for companies that are growing rapidly, but contradictions like this make it very difficult to get a clear sense of rights conferred or removed by the terms.
9. Registration language for under-13s: totally agree; it is tough to direct 10 year olds to this - however, this is why we have a COPPA-compliant signup flow, as certified by Truste. We stream users into teachers, parents and students, and make every effort to stop under-13s signing up as anything except students.
Yeah - COPPA compliance is always going to be tricky. I'm less concerned about a Truste verification than I am about making sure that schools understand their obligations here. As I mentioned earlier, schools are in the best position to do COPPA reviews, but often don't fully understand their obligations. In that case, vendors have a role to play to educate them, but staffing for that when you are offering a free service is a time consuming and expensive proposition.
10. FERPA: we don’t share parent or student information without their explicit consent; it’s as simple as that. FERPA applies to educational institutions, and we help them fulfill their obligations by giving students and parents access to their own information whenever they want it (through parent / student accounts), and not sharing parent or student information, except in accordance with FERPA. I do agree that this section could be clarified - I’ll work on getting some clearer language here.
Yeah, FERPA is another can of worms. Is it possible for a parent to review all of the data you have collected on their kid? I'm assuming that at the very least they can see the behavioral information on their student. But this is also an odd corner of FERPA - a lot of what you collect would arguably not be an educational record, and given that FERPA (in its current form) is more of a funding bill with privacy implications than an actual privacy bill, what would your obligations be under FERPA if a business transaction would benefit from the behavioral data of students?
Let's say that you had a hypothetical deal with a video provider that would offer parents videos based on the student behavior reports. Would FERPA prevent/hinder sharing of student behavioral data with a 3rd party video provider? At the risk of stating the obvious, this is a question for the lawyers, and I suspect that even among the lawyers the answer will be a resounding "maybe."
This is another area where a delete button for parents would support parental rights under FERPA. Parents should have the right to opt their child into or out of a 3rd party service that takes data on their child.
11. Free and paid services: the ‘paid-for’ features mentioned here refer to new features we may develop in the future, that we might charge for - NOT charging for current features or locking-up users’ data. As I have said before, we never sell on or rent information to marketers or advertisers, and will certainly not charge users for access to their own data: they can get it any time in their account, and can have it in other forms at any time by by emailing us at hello@classdojo.com! I can clarify this in the next iteration of this policy.
That clarification would be great. Does ClassDojo support (or plan on supporting) any kind of export API? And, when a parent requests their kid's data, in what format is it delivered?
12. Class action language: I agree that this section seems very legalistic. Our lawyers say it is a standard legal term; frankly, it doesn’t seem material to how we operate every day as a company, but the lawyers insisted on having it in as it is apparently a standard requirement. I do see that many other companies used extensively in education have similar terms in their policies, such as Dropbox () and MineCraftEDU ().
Since reading your comment I went on a hunt for this language in other policies, and it pops up with some frequency both in and out of edu. I've been thinking about this a bit more, and I think I'm coming around to agree with the lawyers. It's a decent protection against frivolous lawsuits. Having human-friendly language here (something like "We're not concerned about any class action lawsuits, but we also know that people do silly and unpredictbale things, and this language gives us some limited protection against this") would be helpful.
Which is a long way of saying - I agree with you on this.
Bill - I hope some of these thoughts help clarify the intent behind the terms and privacy policy. ClassDojo is always evolving and improving, on every front, and your feedback helps us greatly. Our mission is to help teachers, parents & students develop through positive feedback; we’re trying to help students learn the behaviors and skills important to lifelong success by enabling teachers and parents to recognize and encourage those. In order to achieve this, our terms needs to be clear so that teachers, parents and students can all participate with confidence.
I appreciate the spirit of open collaboration and feedback, and I hope this discussion will help us further reflect our operating practices and intentions in legal language. As I mentioned before, our approach to privacy has always been to do what is right by our teachers, parents and students; while legal language can certainly sound scarier than those intentions, this feedback will help us work towards clearer, crisper language.
We’d love further feedback from you (or others on the thread!) as we further clarify our terms and conditions - getting them crystal clear is a top priority for us. Please email me anytime at sam@classdojo.com if there’s anything I can do to help, or if you’d like to discuss further. Thank you once again for the feedback: I’m hoping this can be a model for how all of us trying to do good things in education can work together to make sure we continue to do right by the teachers, students and parents we work with, and care so much about.
I hope that my feedback here has been helpful. For what it's worth (and as is probably obvious) I actually enjoy reading privacy policies. A lot of the issues I described with ClassDojo policies are also present in many other policies. In the fairly near future, time permitting, I'll be putting together a checklist of items for parent, teachers, and district staff to review when they are evaluating services. This conversation has been very helpful for distilling some of these items.

