Is Anyone Within Unions Talking About Open Content?
4 min read
I've written about this a few times, and I'm wondering what movement (if any) there has been within either union leadership or rank and file on open content as a union concern, especially as it relates to teacher professional development and local control. Doing this well would require paid staff time, which is why union involvement is key.
To quote from an earlier blog post on the subject -
At a high level, here is how this could be done:
- If every teacher within a school shared 3-5 of their best units from each course they taught, that translates into a significant amount of useful content that is relevant and successful within a local context.
- If a group of districts agreed to pool the resources shared by teachers from the different schools within the district, the shared content would likely translate into full coverage across a significant portion of the academic requirements across the districts.
- Teacher professional development could be modified into guided working sessions; the purpose of these working sessions would be to clean up, refine, and revise shared curriculum as needed. Districts could hire subject-matter experts (or use the expertise within their teaching or district curriculum staff) to review course materials, and to work with teachers. Teachers could also work with their peers, and the combination of peer to peer feedback with input from subject matter experts would provide a feedback loop that helped keep teachers grounded in subject matter expertise, and subject matter experts grounded in the realities of the classroom.
- The nature of the teacher professional development would shift throughout the year. Before the school year started, classroom teachers would look at and revise existing materials. During the school year, teachers would meet in peer groups and annotate the materials they used, noting what worked, what didn't, and how the lessons could be improved. At the end of the school year, they would collect their notes, and create a summary of needed edits for the course materials. These edits would be based on the collected observations and experiences of classroom teachers. As needed, selected classroom teachers, Teachers on Special Assignment (TOSAs), district-level curriculum staff, and outside experts could revise and modify curriculum over the summer to prepare it for use in the upcoming school year.
This would require significant effort, and a degree of courage and vision within school districts. Creating new curricular materials isn't easy, but it's worth noting that every textbook company is doing it, and that the private companies taking public money are doing it. Within these organizations, many of the authors writing "professional" curriculum have no K12 classroom experience whatsoever. While authoring content takes time and effort, the process is known. Because of the speed at which Common Core adoption is being pushed, many districts are overwhelmed, and it feels easier to throw money to an outside vendor to make the "problem" go away, if only temporarily. But pouring public money out of the district into private hands isn't a viable long term solution. Empowering teachers - or really, providing the opportunity for teachers to empower themselves by direct involvement in the tools they use in their daily work - is the type of local, sustainable investment that reaps dividends over time.
It's also worth noting that this general process could also be applied to developing high quality, locally relevant formative assessments: get the best of what teachers are already using, clean up as needed, get outside support as needed, and revise based on use and observation within the classroom.
One of the many points of releasing material - and especially material that documents the creative and learning process - under an open license is to allow those who come after you the freedom to not reinvent the wheel. Because of the adoption of the Common Core standards in the US, districts across the country are all now scrambling to invent their own version of the wheel.
Whether you like or dislike the standards, their impending adoption creates an opportunity to rethink our dated habits of teacher professional development and sourcing curriculum. Folding curriculum review and peer feedback into teacher professional development has the potential to transform professional development into something actually useful for teachers.
