What Opt Out Leaves Out - On Disaggregated Data

2 min read

The opt out movement is gaining steam. However, current opt out efforts often overlook or gloss over one essential element in the current educational landscape: disaggregated data at the school and district level.

The widespread use of disaggregated data was part of No Child Left Behind. The use of disaggregated data at the school level meant that schools now reported information on different populations within them. Rather than report just a schoolwide average, schools reported on specific populations, based on race and socioeconomic status. This brought increased focus - and in many cases, new focus - on how schools supported or didn't support different populations. The use of disaggregated data provided a starting point for discussing longstanding and long-ignored achievement gaps.

And, while you won't find many people arguing that NCLB was a stunning success, the emphasis on disaggregated data was a change that needed to happen, and that needs to be retained. Without the use of disaggregated data, we would not be having some of the critical conversations about race and socioeconomic status, and how the needs of populations have not been met in many of our schools.

When disaggregated data is left out of the conversations, that lands as, "we will go back to ignoring large numbers of school kids." When people within opt out talk about opting out of tests, though, they are often silent about disaggregated data. This omission isn't necessary, as there are many sources of data about schools, and school climate, and school performance, and alternative forms of assessment, that could be expressed as disaggregated data sets. Until opt out gets clear on the ongoing use of disaggregated data, the opt out message will alienate some potential allies.

, , ,