From a Rumor to the President: Transferring Misinformation in Five Steps

4 min read

UPDATE, October 1, 2019: the Inspector General of the Intelligence Community has taken the unusual step of issuing a statement that says that its process has not been altered. In other words, the ICIG is saying that the misinformation repeated by right wing media, and the president, is not true. END UPDATE

Studying and documenting misinformation can often be abstract and indirect. However, the last week has provided one of the more clear examples of misinformation traveling from a rumor to -- unfortunately -- being repeated as fact by news organizations and government officials. The whole process only took seven days; in this post I break down how the lie was introduced, how it was whitewashed, and how it was amplified.

The short version of this story: a person on Twitter made a post that laid out a false claim on September 23rd. The false claim was amplified in another Twitter thread on September 27th. The content of these two threads were then repackaged into an article on a far right web site. From there, the misinformation spread through multiple other right wing misinformation sites, into right wing pundits, to Fox News, and from there to the President's Twitter feed.

This piece from Kevin Poulsen goes into detail about why the claim is false, and about some of the people who shared the false claim.

The lie that was spread and amplified via misinformation was that the requirements for whistleblowers was mysteriously changed.

Step 1

The misinformation about the "changed requirements" for whistleblowers first appeared in this Twitter thread:

First twitter thread

I'm not linking to the thread to avoid giving it additional visibility (throughout the post, I will not be linking directly to any of the misinformation pieces listed so as to not give them any additional visibility. All of the posts referenced here are available on archive.org; I recommend viewing them there so as not to give any additional visibility to sites spreading misinformation).

This thread misrepresents the language of forms to suggest that the standards for whistleblower complaints were secretly changed. This is, of course, not true, but this lie serves two purposes: first, it is part of the larger multifaceted effort to discredit the whistleblower; and second, it is a dog whistle to the conspiracy theorists who have been pushing the lie that there is a "deep state" that is actively trying to combat Donald Trump.

Step 2

On September 27, the second thread amplified the misinformation of the first thread. This thread looks at the creation date of the pdfs, the revision date on another document, and then launches into a 20+ post thread that uses another standard technique of conspiracy theorists: stacking multiple tangentially related (and largely unsupported) claims in a mammoth thread. The desired effect of juxtaposing numerous unrelated spurious claims is to create a vague sense that "something is wrong" paired with the cognitive overload that comes with trying to sort out why any individual claim is relevant. This technique should be understood as a form of a DDOS on critical thinking. 

Second twitter thread

Again, for a review of why these claims about the whistleblower are unfounded, please see the article from Kevin Poulsen, re-linked again here for convenience.

Step 3

The misinformation contained in the Twitter threads summarized above were largely repackaged into a story posted on The Federalist. The story on the Federalist doesn't contain much new information; it largely regurgitated the screenshots and claims originally shared on Twitter, and added some of the talking points that the White House mistakenly emailed out earlier in the week.

Federalist

The Federalist story, however, attracted attention within the right.

Nunes tweet

Step 4

On Sunday, Fox News invited a right wing pundit on their Sunday Morning "news" program. In this segment, the right wing pundit repeats the lie that the whistleblower requirements were changed. Notably, this false claim was not disputed or checked; for viewers of Fox News, this piece of misinformation has now been presented as reality.

Mediaite - ugh

This piece was shared on Mediaite, a left leaning site that is also known for misinformation and partisan spin. Despite the unreliable source, and the left leaning bias of the source, the president uses this source to congratulate the right wing pundit who amplified the lie about the requirements for whistleblowers.

DJT noticing Fox News clip

Step 5

And finally, earlier today (Monday, September 30th), the personal account of the president of the United States referenced this false claim on his Twitter feed.

Trump question that amplifies misinformation

Conclusion

It's very unusual to have such a clear and concrete example of how misinformation travels from an early rumor into channels that, ideally, would be more reliable. However, in this example, we can trace the migration of false information directly from a twitter thread to the President.