Access Is Not The Same As Ownership: Retaining the Fifth R

2 min read

Darren Draper has a post summarizing some thoughts on David Wiley's proposal for a fifth "R". Both David's and Darren's posts provide context around what I'm writing here.

Textbook rental companies are sprouting like weeds. Publishers have done this to themselves, by positioning themselves as gatekeepers and selling for as high a price as possible. Most of the large textbook companies, like Pearson, have engaged in some strategic moves that blunt some of the impact of textbook rentals. These strategies - openwashing, and diversification into student records, accountability reporting, adaptive learning, and credit recovery, allow them to embed sales of their content under a veneer of "21st Century Learning."

However, the need for the ability to retain access to material we pay for can be seen anywhere these services are used. For example, under the terms of the Los Angeles Unified School District contract with Pearson, the district is spending millions of dollars to lease professional development material. When the contract is up, the content goes away. Similarly, when college students rent a digital version of a text, they lose access at the end of the rental period.

If there was a compelling technical reason why access needed to be revoked, this would be a different conversation. But there is no technical reason driving expiration dates on content. Publishing companies are attempting to sell us on the idea that our access to information should be constrained for their need for a business model. Without a focus on the right to retain access, we reduce our options. Four years ago, when Amazon defined irony by removing copies of 1984 from people's devices, there was some outcry. We haven't made much progress - in terms of our rights to retain the material to which we have access - since then. By recognizing the right to retain our access to the tools from which we learn, we situate control where it should be: with the learner, and their inquiry.

, , ,

Evaluating Privacy Policies, and Helping Others Do It Well

2 min read

In December, 2013, the Fordham Center on Law and Information Policy released a study on privacy and cloud computing in public schools within the US.

The study is a worthwhile read - I'm cleaning up my notes from several passes through it and will be putting them out in the form of a (long, messy) blog post later this week, but I wanted to highlight a "Document Coding Checklist" the authors created for the study, and included as Appendix B.

To highlight this work, I excerpted the checklist* from the study and included it here as an attachment (pdf download). The requirements defined in the checklist could be applied by any district, principal, or teacher when evaluating a piece of software or cloud-based service. A deep dive into the background knowledge required to accurately apply this checklist should be a one or two day professional development session. If the materials used for preparing and delivering this session were made available as open educational resources, under a Creative Commons license, it would be possible for a large number of people to get a much-needed crash course in the legalities of student privacy. This benefits teachers, students, parents, districts, policymakers - really, just about anyone affected by this issue.

Learning how to apply the checklist isn't a silver bullet for privacy issues, but the checklist provides a concrete starting point that people can use to discuss what privacy does or doesn't mean with regards to a specific service. The concept of privacy is complex; current approaches to privacy are convoluted and opaque; learning how to apply this checklist provides a means to address both of those issues.

* This checklist was created by the authors of the study, and is © 2013 by the Fordham Center on Law and Information Policy

, , , , ,

Value Added, and FERPA

1 min read

Until proponents of Value Added teacher ratings can explain how Mark Berndt was a solid educator, the use of Value Added rankings as part of any teacher evaluation plan is pathetically, harmfully myopic.

According to the logic of Value Added, Mark Berndt was actually improving - look at how his Value Add in math climbed from 2009.

On a related note, Mark Berndt created a data trail on the students in his classroom. How much of that data trail is still intact? What would a FERPA review (pdf download) of that data look like? What recourse does a family have when a teacher is removed from the classroom? If a person isn't fit to be teaching are they still fit to be contributing to the story of how a student learns?

, , ,

Teaching About the Jordan Davis Murder

19 min read

This post is a collaborative effort from a group of people for teaching about the Jordan Davis murder.

[This post represents the work of a group of educators and education activists who wanted to help educators help students process the verdict in the Jordan Davis murder trial. Many of us wrote from our experiences both in and out of the classroom, and as such, many of us used “I” statements in talking about these ideas. The writers are Melinda Anderson, Joshua Block, Zac Chase, Alexa Dunn, Bill Fitzgerald, Matt Kay, Diana Laufenberg, me, Luz Maria Rojas, John Spencer, Mike Thayer, Jose Vilson and Audrey Watters. You can also link to the Google Doc or the whole thing as a PDF. Everything written below is collaborative. This document is Creative Commons - Share Alike. I only add that as educators, this is a way we can make the world just a little bit better - by talking, by trying, by teaching. There are many other ways our society has to address the issues that Jordan Davis' murder demands we face. But as teachers, we have our classrooms. We can all can start there. -- Chris Lehmann]

As educators we believe that we have a responsibility to use our classrooms to help young people grapple with and address the messiness of the world around them. In collaborating on this, what we know to be true is that there is more than a single lesson plan here. The issues raised by the Jordan Davis murder trial touch deeply on issues of race, law, social justice, and any and all of these issues could be a course of study. What we hope to do is offer a number of ways for teachers and students to think about the case while knowing that no one way, no one day can possibly speak to all of the challenges this case represents.

What follows is an attempt to organize what was a 15-hour brainstorming session into a few organizing concepts – 1) things to consider as a teacher when tackling this subject, 2) ideas and resources around teaching about / toward the Jordan Davis murder verdict, and 3) some concrete lesson plans that teachers could use that examine the verdict from several different lenses.

General Thoughts About Teaching Toward The Jordan Davis Murder and Verdict:

  • Many teachers are a little uncomfortable, maybe even afraid, to have these conversations, but that’s exactly why we need to have them. Importantly, these conversations also need to happen among the adults in the building as well. Many of the ideas in this post could also be used for professional development sessions with the adults.
  • Pay attention to the context of your classroom. If it is a predominately white classroom, please don’t use the minority student as the “expert informant” whose job it is to “tell it like it is.” That’s a whole lot of pressure to put on a kid. On the same note, if you teach in a school where students are mostly African-American (or students of color in general), share how you feel about it, how it makes you angry and sad. Then give them space to talk about it.
  • Give students the permission to process in a way that represents who they are. Some kids want to talk about it. Some want to listen. Some want to blog about it. I’ve had some kids sketch their ideas out in word bubbles or in art while we try to make sense out of the tragedy. Talking to Children About Violence: Tips for Parents and Teachers
  • I would caution teachers that some kids (including African-Americans) might not feel as crushed by it as they do. Some students have normalized injustice. Some students have seen things that we can’t fathom and it’s hard for them that their own stories of injustice were never deemed “newsworthy.” Some students are just not that interested in the moment in an even that feels “far away” from them. Kids don’t want to feel emotionally manipulated by any adult – especially a teacher. (very important to remember, well said)
  • I think it helps sometimes to make the distinction ahead of time that discomfort doesn’t mean “unsafe.” It might not be a comfortable conversation, but hopefully it will be a safe, trusted environment. I know that I’ve had to go over this concept when talking about racial injustice in immigration policy.
  • On issues that have significant emotional impact, I like to start the class with the opportunity for personal reflection and thought-gathering before getting into group discussion. One process I used was to open the class with a background reading, and give students blank index cards. After they have read the background piece, they write one adjective describing their thoughts on the piece. Then, the cards get collected and displayed in a publicly visible space. This process creates the room for people to all get familiarity with the issue, along with some time to collect thoughts/emotions before starting discussions.
  • Keep developmental level of kids in mind. The way I talked with my older son (3rd grade) is different from how I’ll talk to 8th graders.
  • Plan the lesson, not as scripted, because you cannot script this conversation, but be aware that just having an open-ended conversation with kids may unintentionally create the space where kids don’t feel safe or o.k. to have the conversation. Small group discussions, writing prompts, time for reflections, and the setting of norms for these conversations can help to create a place where kids feel safe to have what will quite possibly be a very uncomfortable conversation.
  • I think it’s important to say that we will not “solve” this problem in an hour-long class, and we have to be thoughtful about owning that upfront.
  • That said, it is important to really be aware of time when dealing with topics like this. it isn’t fair to kids to get so caught up in the conversation as to lose track of time and then just “dismiss” the kids when class is over without giving students the opportunity to have some closure on the conversation you are having, even if many of us are at a place where we have don’t closure on what actually happened.

Ideas and Resources For Teaching The Jordan Davis Murder Verdict:

  • Apparently Don Lemon was furious about the verdict. Seems as good an anticipatory set as anything else: http://www.mediaite.com/tv/%E2%80%98yes-i-am-pissed%E2%80%99-don-lemon-goes-off-on-dunn-trial-there-should-be-%E2%80%98mind-your-business%E2%80%99-law/
  • What is the relationship between law and justice? Can be connected to excerpts from Thoreau on Civil Disobedience.
  • How do societies change? What is the role of individuals to demand change? Can connect to 198 Methods of Nonviolent Action. I find that some students respond to issues by saying, “That’s just the way things are…” I believe it is crucial to remind young people that history is filled with struggles for and periods of change. Film clips can be very helpful to remind students of historical moments when people mobilized to demand change. Here is a powerful clip from Egypt. The film The Democratic Promise has some parts that resonate with students. (It is in parts on YouTube. This is part 1.)
  • Patricia Hill Collins’ book The Alchemy of Race and Rights has a powerful section on Critical Legal Studies using the example of Eleanor Bumpers. She does a great job picking apart the way society and language can steer the conversation away from what is morally right. It is a great starting point for picking apart something like Stand Your Ground.
  • Depending on the age and the group people can consider using some of Augusto Boal’s tools from Theater of the Oppressed. This activity from Training for Change is another possibility for enabling students to explore ways to speak up against injustice.
  • Ta-Nehisi Coates has a powerful essay about the verdict in the Atlantic. http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/02/on-the-killing-of-jordan-davis-by-michael-dunn/283870/
  • One thing I have been thinking about is the ease with which certain words get thrown around, like “thug”; is there a place within the conversation with the kids to talk about how the words they use matter? Perhaps finding examples in media of how language is used to support stereotypes and how language can also subvert them?
  • Another thing I have thought about is the role of schools in teaching empathy. Is it a good idea to include in the lesson a place for students to practice deep listening? http://www.contemplativemind.org/practices/tree/deep-listening
  • This could be an interesting way into the conversation… this would take some time, but if someone was interested in building this into more than a day http://sfi.usc.edu/creatingcharacter/docs/LP_JusticeFairness_CC_002.pdf
  • I would address some of the facts of the trial and also the humanity behind it. The CNN video where Jordan Davis’s parents talk about him is powerful, because he retains his humanity.
  • I would make sure that some time is spent (after the initial chat about the feelings in the room) learning about the history of stand your ground laws. http://www.nyclu.org/knowyourrights
  • I would make sure that some time is spent going over that terms like “murder” and “manslaughter” mean. And the choices that prosecutors make when going for each distinction — and how “Stand Your Ground” affects those choices in Florida.
  • There is enough “living history” from the civil rights movement still around – I would find a way to bring in someone who was around for Emmett Till (Possible Resource – http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/eyesontheprize/story/01_till.html) (or any other such vigilante injustice) and have a conversation linking now and “then.” I am bringing in a few folks to speak to my kids about the race riots that they have witnessed – could be a similar opportunity. And if the notice is too short – there is no shortage of 1st person interviews / news reports / other primary sources to explore and pick through for similarities. No shortage of questions to ask about what they see.
  • I have had some fairly explosive conversations about my own dealings with the police / would be vigilantes / and so have many of my mentees and students. I think that any conversation has to take into account that many of them have their own stories to tell about this kind of injustice – and they need to be given the space to talk. Many of the kids have stop and frisk stories that they would be quick to relate to what happened in these famous cases. Their family members have been through it. Many opportunities for connection.
  • After the Trayvon Martin murder verdict, the QED Foundation published a page of resources for talking to kids about the verdict. Some of these links may be useful entry points for talking with kids about the Jordan Davis case: http://qedfoundation.org/resources-for-talking-to-your-kids-about-the-case-of-trayvon-martin
  • I screen Spike Lee’s Do the Right Thing (a well done film review by Roger Ebert) in Senior Reel Reading and we explore how this film is a vehicle for social commentary. One character, Radio Raheem, is killed by white police after an enraged incident in Sal’s Pizzeria over the volume of his boom box. However, it’s not so black and white (pardon the pun), and there are many, many gray areas. Versions of this kind of story can be seen in the Howard Beach incident (which inspired Do the Right Thing), the Jordan Davis case, and countless cases in between and yet to come. While a 1989 film, it is still so relevant today.
  • I want them to maybe look at some key PA laws here and compare to Florida laws. “How am I in danger?” “Am I?” I want my students to see AZ laws and the fact that they’re currently fast-tracking a Stand Your Ground Law in our state.

One Possible Lesson Plan: Target Age – Grades 7-12

Warm up: What is Justice? Provide examples. What is injustice? Provide examples. Discuss. Collect examples on the board or digitally.

Provide students with scenarios that allow them to take a stand on whether something was just or unjust. Suggestions – students can jot down their thoughts first and then use the ‘stand on a line’ or ‘opinion continuum’ activity for students to indicate where they fall on the just, unjust spectrum with each of the scenarios.

Scenario 1: A family is forcibly interned (confined for political or military reasons) for 2 years because they are American citizens of Japanese descent and the government decided they were dangerous. (Reference)

Just or Unjust. Explain your thoughts.

Scenario 2: Homeowners lost their homes in order to make room for a General Motors plant to be built. They were fairly compensated by the government for the cost of their property but were not given a choice to sell or not sell. (Reference)

Just or Unjust. Explain your thoughts.

Scenario 3: 16-year-old drives while drunk and kills 4 people. He receives probation and no jail time for the crime. (Reference)

Just or Unjust. Explain your thoughts.

Scenario 4: Children are removed from their homes and taken to boarding schools where they are taught that their native language is bad and must learn English, take ‘western’ names and adopt western customs in order to fit into American culture better. (Reference)

Just or Unjust. Explain your thoughts.

Scenario 5: A man was released from death row after 15 years when DNA evidence was used to clear him of wrong-doing in the murder of his cousin. (Reference)

Just or Unjust. Explain your thoughts.

Then introduce the basic facts of the Jordan Davis case, including information on Stand Your Ground and self-defense – ask students to write down questions as they hear the facts of the case. Allow time for question and answer time.

Have students develop statements about how justice and injustice relate to this case.

Play/read different perspectives of people after the verdict. Discuss the emotions and frustration felt by many Americans as a result of the verdict.

Talk about action steps… if one wanted to speak out against or DO something … what are options. Brainstorm and then teachers shares ones not mentioned. Such as:

  • Register to Vote – Encourage Parents to Register to Vote
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Discussions with parents/family
  • Use social media to bring about awareness amongst peers
  • Keep up to date with current events and issues of social justice
  • Be aware of local issues of injustice
  • Lead a school wide day on issues of social justice
  • Start a youth group to discuss issues of social justice and bring awareness

Resources to continue the conversation:

Another Potential Lesson Plan: Target Age – 7th – 12th Grade:

I think lesson plans that bring up pertinent questions that help kids wrestle with the subject are most useful. Especially I would like the lesson plan to help kids see that Jordan Davis is emblematic of what happens in schools via zero tolerance and black males disproportionately affected by suspensions/expulsions. When does an innocent high school student become “intimidating,” “threatening” or “suspicious”? That’s why “Stand Your Ground” laws are so flawed – because its underpinning is that bodily harm or death is justified if the person feels intimidated or threatened – people can feel threatened if they are scared or paranoid about their safety. How does “intimidating,” “threatening” or “suspicious” look in their classrooms, their schools, in their daily interactions outside school – by exploring from their own experiences, that to me as a parent would be most valuable. My son has said that he notices people judge him and his friends by their appearance, depending on how he’s dressed. It makes him feel self-conscious. Maybe explore those concepts:

Journal Entry:

Have you ever had a moment where you felt that someone judged you because of your perceived race, gender, age, religion, sexual orientation and/or manner of dress? How did that make you feel? Or have you ever judged someone based on those perceived attributes?

Discussion:

In small groups, have students discuss their personal reactions to the journal entry for several moments. Then ask groups to share out with the class what they discussed.

Transition / Class discussion prompt:

  • What are your concerns when people make judgements based on those perceived attributes?

Activity:

Have students read the New York Times article on the Jordan Davis case:

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/16/us/florida-killing-over-loud-music.html

In small groups, have students take on the following questions and then share out:

  • Why did Michael Dunn see Jordan Davis as a threat?
  • Why did Michael Dunn feel threatened by someone sitting in a car, listening to loud music?
  • Why do these kind of thoughts surface in people’s heads when they see a black person?
  • Would things have been different if Jordan Davis was a white kid sitting in his car, listening to loud music? Why or why not?

Big Questions:

  • What does it mean when institutional decisions (for example, court cases, school policies, employment opportunities, housing) are influenced by this kind of pre-judging / stereotyping?
  • How does it affect us if we believe a decision was made because of the way someone perceived us due to our perceived race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, and/or manner of dress?
  • What does it mean when laws or policies like “Stand Your Ground” or school suspension policies have a disproportionate negative impact on people of color more than whites?

Summary:

  • What can be done to help people be better informed about those they see as “others” based on the perceived identifiers above?
  • What needs to happen to make sure that laws and policies do not reinforce existing inequality in our country and in our communities?
  • What can we do as a community to begin and support that work?

Potential Lesson Plan: Target Age – 7th – 12th Grade

The goal of this lesson plan is to give students the chance to talk about the trial, about their feelings about it, and then do meaningful, real work that allows them to address the problems they see in the trial / the law.

Do now:

Read one of three articles about the trial:

Give students blank index cards. After they have read the background piece, students write one adjective describing their thoughts on the piece. Then, the cards get collected and displayed in a publicly visible space. This process creates the room for people to all get familiarity with the issue, along with some time to collect thoughts/emotions before starting discussions.

Discussion:

  • What do you think of the verdict? Was justice served? Why or why not?

Short write – Potential Topics:

  • What is the relationship between the way I feel about this personally and what I can do as a person in America?
  • How is what happened to Jordan Davis relevant to me?
  • How does this compare to my world? My experiences? What does it say about America? My city? My state?

Activity:

In small groups, come up with an action plan about what can be done to make a more just society / country / community. Some potential activities include:

  • Blog post about “What should society / can we as a community do after the Jordan Davis murder trial?” – maybe even an open-ended blog post with several options (a brainstorm of blog topics crowd-sourced in small groups)
  • A letter to Jordan Davis’ parents
  • A letter to local politicians
  • An Op-Ed for the local newspaper
  • A meeting with local law enforcement to discuss concerns around the case.
  • Given that the Jordan Davis murder verdict is not something isolated, it would also be good to brainstorm with students about any plans/interest for ongoing involvement/activism.

Summary:

  • How do we deal with a tragedy and work to make change?
  • How do we act in the public good when we are angry, sad, frustrated, hurt, scared?
  • How do we do it as a community and not just as individuals who feel all of the above emotions?

Final thought: Thank the kids for being willing to engage in the conversation. And tell them you love them. And mean it.

, ,

Did Louisiana Leave inBloom, or Did inBloom Leave Louisiana? And Why the Answer Doesn't Really Matter

12 min read

NOTE: This is a long piece. I won't be (too) offended if you skip right to the conclusion. END NOTE

When people write about the story of inBloom, they generally note that Louisiana was the first state to stop using inBloom. The story is usually told with the exit as Louisiana's decision, made in response to parental outrage over data sharing.

The question of whether or not inBloom was storing Social Security numbers (SSNs) of students raised many initial questions, and the initial responses did little to address these concerns.

From looking at how inBloom's language around SSNs evolved over time, it seems like they started from a place of "we really don't want any SSNs" and ended up at "we won't store SSNs, period."

Shortly after the inBloom launch, I looked at the inBloom data model. This didn't tell us much, as it appeared that inBloom would defer to the student identifier supplied by the state, which may or may not be a SSN.

On April 1, 2013 - the day I wrote this post, inBloom's FAQ included the following language on SSNs:

inBloom discourages storing social security numbers in its data service, but legally school districts and state may record student social security numbers. inBloom prohibits storage of social security numbers in the data store unless agreed to by both inBloom and the state/district on a case-by-case basis.

As of https://www.inbloom.org/faq">June 6th, 2013, that language had been changed to read:

inBloom does not and will not accept social security numbers (SSNs) as unique student identifiers. No SSNs are currently in the data store. In the past, our policy has been to prohibit the use of SSNs as unique identifier unless the state or district applied for a waiver to that policy. No such waivers were ever issued, and going forward inBloom will prohibit the use of SSNs under any circumstances and will not offer waivers.

The current version of the inBloom FAQ includes no references to SSNs at all, and instead highlights that inBloom operates under FERPA.

It's both interesting and informative to track this evolution alongside a couple of letters from inBloom's CEO, Iwan Streichenberger. At the outset, however, I must highlight that neither of these letters are retrieved from the inBloom website. The first, undated letter, was sent out to inBloom partners in spring of 2013, and was retrieved from the Jefferson County, CO, Schools website. The second letter, dated June 17, 2013, was retrieved from Jason France's Crazy Crawfish blog. I'm attaching copies of both letters to this post in case the linked versions disappear. Both of these letters look real; both have been publicly available for months, and the authenticity of both letters has not been challenged, but in the interest of being excessively cautious I want to be clear about where I found these letters.

In the first undated letter - written to inBloom partners shortly after the public announcement that Louisiana was pausing data storage with inBloom on April 24th - Streichenberger provides some background information:

Louisiana was a Phase 2 state in the inBloom consortium, which means it was on a slower implementation track than Phase 1 states. A few months ago, the team in Louisiana saw an opportunity to move more quickly to use the shared services for some key initiatives.

We'll return to these "key initiatives" in Louisiana shortly. The letter continues:

The pause also supports Louisiana’s efforts to transition from using Social Security numbers (SSNs) to randomized student I.D. numbers, in keeping with inBloom’s requirements and with industry best practices. Our team has been working with Louisiana on this issue, and we look forward to continuing to support their efforts in this regard.

It's worth noting that, as highlighted in this letter written in 2013, Louisiana is still using SSNs to identify students. This is particularly problematic given that, in 2009, Louisiana was given a 4 million dollar federal grant to develop a statewide data system. Moreover, the terms of the program under which the grant was given explicitly require that all students have anonymized unique identifiers. Yet, despite this influx of federal money, Louisiana was still using SSNs for student identifiers.

The theme of SSNs being used as student identifiers is picked up in the second letter, written by Streichenberger to John White, the Louisiana state superintendent of education. In this letter, Streichenberger is informing White that inBloom will no longer work with Louisiana.

During the course of planning for implementation in Louisiana, the inBloom team engaged in discussions with state personnel regarding how the state might transition from the use of SSNs to randomized student I.D. numbers. As we worked through this issue and to support the state's Course Choice program, it came to inBloom's attention that Louisiana was nevertheless uploading student SSNs to its secure storage space on the inBloom system.
We acknowledge that discussions were held regarding whether Louisiana could receive a waiver in accordance with the language in the contract. As you know, however, that matter was discussed and rejected, and inBloom did not issue a waiver for Louisiana. Consistent with best practices and based on our recent experiences, we have since changed our policies to prohibit even a temporary waiver, so that no SSNs are uploaded to inBloom's system.

This excerpt highlights five key points:

  1. Confirms Louisiana is using SSNs for student identifiers;
  2. inBloom gave good advice: DON'T USE SSNs!
  3. As discussed above, inBloom changed their SSN policy while working with Louisiana
  4. Louisiana ignored inBloom's recommendations, and were fired as a result. The fact that inBloom needed to sever the relationship also calls into question White's claim (from April 2013) that data sharing with inBloom was paused.
  5. inBloom was slated to be used used for Louisiana's Course Choice program.

The connection between Course Choice and inBloom is rarely explored in any detail. Later in this post, we'll look at this further. But before we get there, let's take a glance at what part of John White's world looked like in April 2013.

Denied!

As of http://www.louisianacoursechoice.net/">April 5th, 2013, LouisianaCourseChoice.net is dead to the world. John White and Bobby Jindal are pushing choice as an option. Despite a May state Supreme Court ruling that the funding mechanisms for school choice aren't constitutional, White finds the money anyways. However, the Course Choice system - as it currently stands - uses social security numbers. Whether that's a peculiarity of the Course Choice system or of Louisiana's educational records - which have not yet transitioned to randomly generated IDs - is unclear, but time is running short, and the site needs to launch. If Course Choice isn't live in time to support students leaving public schools by August 2013, it will not be good. The Course Choice system needs the dataset, the Course Choice system needs to go live, so uploading data into the datastore while explicitly ignoring the privacy advice of one of your tech parters seems like a good idea - because hey - what are the Social Security numbers of all the kids in a state among friends?

The irony here is that it sounds like inBloom gave White sound advice, and White - for whatever reason - ignored it. Politically, the only palatable option White has is to claim that he pulled out of collaborating with inBloom because he listened to privacy concerns. Conversely, inBloom can't burn a client by publicly stating that the client ignored technical advice and uploaded sensitive student data, and that the client was fired as a result. This leaves us with the story that we have: that Louisiana started the exodus of inBloom partners nationwide.

However, the role the Louisiana Course Choice program and web site also merit attention. The reason that inBloom dumped White centered around the need for SSNs in the Course Choice site. It's completely unclear whether the site still uses student SSNs and provides them to course vendors or not. This points to the elephant in the room around state-level longitudinal data systems: it's currently a zero-sum game. There are a small number of options, and if a state isn't using one, it's using another. Course Choice went live with another system (likely delivered, supported, and possibly hosted by another vendor) serving data, with the same weak privacy practices. Because of the focus on inBloom, the systemic questions that would actually protect student data (starting with "Why are SSNs being used as identifiers in 2013?") remain unanswered.

Additionally, the Course Choice site contains a small text-based link in the top right corner of the site: "Created by Agilix." This press release from March 2, 2013 highlights the connections between Course Choice, Agilix, inBloom, and John White's vision of how they work together.

John White, Superintendent of Louisiana Schools, says, “By connecting to IBDS (inBloom Data Standard), Agilix opens a lot of doors for our Course Choice product not only for registration but also for detailed analysis of student performance. We expect this will assist greatly in tracking and reporting results of Course Choice adoption to state authorities.”

If you follow education technology, you can see Agilix popping up in reform centers nationwide. Tom Vander Ark praises Buzz, an Agilix-developed system currently in use in Michigan's Education Achievement Authority. Not everybody is as excited about Buzz as Vander Ark, though. In a piece from Michigan Public Radio, State Representative Ellen Cogen Lipton describes conversations she had with students in schools using Buzz.

"They said, 'Buzz is a joke, it's not challenging, it's demeaning.' I asked them if they liked their school better now or before and they said, 'Before.' When I asked why, one student said, 'Look around this room. Do you see any books? I really miss my books,'" Cogen Lipton said.

We also see Agilix-developed software in use within KIPP schools. Agilix is also developing partnerships with textbook companies to market Common Core aligned products to districts and states.

The example of Agilix shows how companies can thrive in the current educational climate. Agilix has had a series of projects with entities that receive public money. In Louisiana, Agilix worked on a system to streamline registration for courses outside the public school system. In Michigan, Agilix worked with schools receiving public money to develop and beta test learning software.

This is all legal, but we need to recognize and call this out for what it is: a private entity received public money to bootstrap the development of a proprietary product that is then sold to public entities and paid for with yet more public money.

This Is Why It Doesn't Matter Whether Louisiana Left inBloom, or Vice Versa

With the focus on inBloom, we conveniently lose sight of the context within which these discussions occur. As noted in this post, Louisiana moved ahead without inBloom, but with the same ineffective data management strategies. Companies like Agilix capitalize on the opportunities within the educational landscape, and larger questions about data collection and privacy go unaddressed. Agilix highlights that it works well with Chromebooks. However, a school using Chromebooks puts student data into Google's ecosystem, and into the hands of any developers whose apps are used within that ecosystem - and no one is talking coherently about the rights of students with regards to their work living in these systems.

But taking another step back, current education policy ensures that we will always have a pool of schools that are deemed failing. The "solution" to these "failing" schools often involve experiments with school closure, staffing schools with less experienced educators like Teach For America recruits, firing principals, firing teachers, and experimenting with technology. One rationale frequently cited for this experimental churn in our most vulnerable schools is that conditions are so bad, that "we have to do something." However, it's worth asking whether the experimental churn fuels the problems it's intended to solve.

There is no denying, however, that school turnaround is good business. Because a "failing" school is defined as the lowest performing 5% as measured on standardized tests, it should surprise absolutely no one that businesses plans exist that depend on the manufactured need to "turn around" these failing schools.

Fortunately, Agilix (and companies like them) are here to help:

Compass Learning, Inc., Agilix Labs, Inc. and School Improvement Network announced today a joint effort to help improve the five percent of historically lowest-performing public schools in the state of Michigan.

This is why the names don't matter. inBloom, Agilix, Pearson, InfiniteCampus, Clever - if all of these organizations went away tomorrow, a new group would crop up to take their place because federal education policy creates the need for them. Federal education policy simultaneously defines a pool of vulnerable schools, and creates the conditions that allows these schools to be fodder for the latest technological or policy fad.

The problems with our conversations about student privacy mirror some of the problems of our conversations about education. Both sets of conversations position the student as an object to be observed, rather than as an informed agent making rational choices. Until we get our heads around the reality that students are the reason our education system exists - and back up that rhetoric by ensuring students have a controlling voice in the collection of, use of, and reflections on any data arising from their education - we'll continue to miss the point.

, , , , , , ,

I Am Not With You

2 min read

I am not with you if you co-opt past horrors to score rhetorical points.

I am not with you if you use gendered stereotypes.

I am not with you if you whitewash discussions of privilege.

I am not with you if you amplify voices doing any of the above things.

I will never stop advocating for schools that are in the best interests of kids and teachers. I care about ensuring that public education remains public, and that people get the resources they need - inside and outside schools. I also realize that my voice is just one of many, and that we all have our stories to tell. I understand the passion, the frustration, the anger.

But I will not stand with you if, in the name of social justice via education, you trample on issues of social justice. I will not stand with you if you use the facile reasoning that "we need to be provocative" in order to get attention. I will not stand with you if you justify intellectual laziness, hyperbole, and factual inaccuracy as okay because "the other side" is working to hurt kids.

I won't stop advocating. I won't stop my work. But I reject - completely - the notion that by calling attention to privilege, racism, sexism, and hyperbole, I am doing anybody a disservice, or "not understanding the magnitude of the problem."

I will talk with anyone about issues of education, or issues of social justice. I will do my best to listen, and to understand, and to reserve judgement for as long as possible. I make no claim of expertise, and fully anticipate being wrong on many things. But - even if I agree with your general positions on what teaching and learning should be - I will not blindly follow if you attempt to bring up Tuskegee, the Holocaust, slavery, or gender-based insults as rhetorical devices. I will not ignore basic errors of fact simply because I happen to agree with some of what you say.

That is not okay, and that is not my fight.

,

Student Data and the Transition to College

2 min read

If organizations collecting and advocating for student data use want to make a difference in helping students transition to college, there are two things they could do pretty immediately that would have an immediate impact on reducing barriers to attending and transitioning into college:

  • Pre-seed the Common Application with information from the district and/or state level datastores; and
  • Pre-seed the Federal Student Aid form with data from district and/or state level datastores.

I suspect that some vendors are already doing this, especially with products that are marketed to the independent school world.

There are practical hurdles around privacy that need to be considered, as well as details like the PIN required to use federal education web sites. But the process of applying to college is pretty paperwork intensive, and one thing data systems are good at is eliminating needless repetition around duplicate data entry.

On the technical side, I don't think that either the FAFSA or the Common App web sites have an API to simplify this type of automation. I would love to be wrong here.

Given that district and state level datastores are currently in use and have all this information, we should leverage them to minimize barriers for students between high school and college. College applicants would still need to do work to complete these forms, but the repetitive elements could be eliminated.

If there are organizations currently working on this type of integration, please, let me know - I would love to learn more about them. I suspect that there is effort underway to do something like what I'm talking about here, but that I haven't heard about it yet.

Just Because You're Pissed About Common Core Doesn't Mean You Get To Use Gendered Stereotypes

4 min read

Dr. Alan Singer put out a piece on Huffington Post Education today ostensibly about how New York State education officials don't want to hear about objections to the Common Core standards. However, the piece goes off the rails into a criticism of a single person, and any point gets lost in the process.

The first seven paragraphs rehash New York education politics, including a summary of the New York Regents Research Fellows. In the eighth paragraph, things get messy.

On the EngageNY website and for the Regents Research Fund the chief salesperson for Common Core is Kate Gerson, a very attractive woman who appears to have minimal teaching experience. Although she is not an actual employ of the State Education Department, Gerson represents them at Common Core meetings across the state and is the featured Common Core cheerleader on EngageNY online videos.

Let's take a step back here. Kate Gerson actually has a title: Senior Fellow at USNY Research Fund. Singer knows this, because he links to her LinkedIn profile later in the article. Calling her a "salesperson" is an underhanded swipe. If things stopped there, this could be defensible.

However, Singer proceeds to refer to Gerson as "a very attractive woman with minimal teaching experience." If the point here is to highlight Gerson's lack of classroom experience, her physical appearance is irrelevant. While authorial intent is difficult to ascertain, Singer certainly appears to be playing on sexist stereotypes of women being promoted based on their looks, rather than their ability.

In the next sentence, Singer proceeds to call Gerson "a cheerleader", thus cementing the gender-based efforts to undermine the credibility of Gerson.

For those of you reading along here who don't see how Singer's words play on stereotypes, try this: if you are a male, find a woman colleague, preferably someone above you in the hierarchy. Tell them how attractive they are. Follow it up by telling them that they are as pretty as a cheerleader. Then, ask them if their cheerleader-pretty looks helped them overcome their lack of experience in their career.

Singer responded to criticism with a comment on Huffington Post.

I thought about the way I described [Kate Gerson] a lot because I did not want to reenforce anti-female stereotypes. Watch the video. They are using her to market common core and she has been rapidly promoted because she acquiesced to being spotlighted this way. I believe they chose her to be their inspirational speaker because she comes across like a female talking head on the television news. My intent was not to offend. I consider myself a feminist and resent the way they use her and the way she has agreed to be used.

I'm not going to digress into definitions of feminism because there are countless other people who can do it better than me, with a perspective that I am not capable of bringing. But I'll leave it here: whether you agree or disagree with Common Core, using gender-based stereotypes as part of your argument doesn't further the conversation. If you want to highlight someone's experience, talk about their experience. If you want to highlight points of disagreement, make your argument. Ideally, suggest something different or better. Using the wrong means to make what you consider to be the right point doesn't help.

NOTE: On April 27th, a person giving her name as "Wendy" commented on this post. The comment was thoughtful and used her direct experience working with her child to ground her concerns with the Common Core rollout. I posted a response to this comment. Then, unfortunately, while cleaning out spam comment, I accidentally deleted her original comment and my response. Wendy - if you are reading this, I am incredibly sorry. I appreciate the time you made to comment, and regret that my mistake removed your comment. I care - a lot - about people discussing and sharing their ideas, even in the face of disagreement. I am incredibly sorry that my mistake deleted your contribution. That's not how I like to do things.END NOTE

, ,

The Day And The Data; Catching Policy Up To Reality

8 min read

In discussions about student privacy and data collection, it's easy to remain stuck on small pieces of the larger picture. In the interest of showing a more complete picture, it's worth looking at the data trail that could be created from a single day of learning. To guide us on this journey, we will work with Sondra*, a sixteen year old high school student. Sondra is enrolled in her local public school. She plays basketball, and takes a regular courseload.

1. The Day

A. Waking Up

Sondra wakes up at 6:30. She has left her school-issued iPad (part of the schools 1:1 iPad initiative) on and charging all night. Her school has Google Apps; she messages Amy, her girfriend, and says a quick "hello" via hangout.

B. Homeroom

On her way to school, Sondra stops off and gets coffee. She had been up late the night before, and mornings are always difficult. The caffeine helps her get moving. As a result, though, she is late to school, which is reported by her homeroom teacher.

C. History - In Class Research

In her World History class, the teacher has them research Napoleon's invasion of Russia. Her school is part of Microsoft's Bing For Schools program, and the teacher has them compare search results from Google, Bing, and Duck Duck Go.

They store notes with information from their searches in a Google doc.

D. English - Handing In A Paper

In her English 10 class, she has a paper due. Because her teacher is lazy, doesn't trust his students, and has never put in the time or effort to learn the writing styles of his students, he uses TurnItIn.com to collect papers and check for plagiarism.

While Sondra and her classmates hand in their papers, she sees her teacher writing on a notepad. He is planning his presentation for ISTE: Technology Integration in the Writing Process.

E. Lunch

Sondra gets hot lunch - pizza, salad, and water. She also gets some potato chips as a snack. She pays with her swipe card.

F. Testing

Sondra's school is field testing the Smarter Balanced tests. As a result, she spends 90 minutes after lunch taking a sample math exam.

G. Basketball Practice

That afternoon, during basketball practice, Sondra lands on the side of her foot after getting a rebound. Eventually, she's able to walk it off. Her coach is tracking types of injuries during specific drills, and he makes a note of Sondra's sprained ankle.

H. Study Group

After basketball practice, Sondra is meeting up with some friends at Starbucks (not the the one at the indoor mall, the one at the strip mall). It's a little out of her way, but she swings by Amy's house to say hi. Sondra's parents have told her not too, and while Sondra hasn't come out to them yet, she thinks they might know, and she's pretty sure that they will freak out. But she has 15 minutes to spare, so she makes the detour.

At the study group, they do more work on Napoleon's invasion of Russia, using Bing for Schools to search, and storing notes in a Google Doc. After working for an hour, Sondra heads home, arriving around 7.

2. The Data

A. Waking Up

Many schools put tracking devices on school issued devices; this basically converts the iPad into a personal tracking device. This data is accessible by the school, and is usually stored on servers provided by the vendor selling the tracking service. Because Sondra left the device on all night, the location of her iPad (and by extension, Sondra) can be tracked for the entire night. Using a Google service lets Google know who Sondra is talking with, and when.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • Google;
  • Apple, or whatever company is tracking iPad location.

B. Homeroom

Attendance data is stored in the school's Student Information System. As noted above, the iPad is set to collect geolocation info, which is also stored. Theoretically, the school could attempt to track Sondra's location (and, possibly, the reason for her tardiness). Some districts are already doing this.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • The school's Student Information System (SIS) - this can be onsite, or an offsite solution managed by a vendor like Pearson or Follett. There are many options here, and running the SIS offsite, on a vendor's hardware, is pretty common;
  • Geolocation data, as noted above.

C. History - In Class Research

Searching sends student data to both Google and Microsoft.

Using Duck Duck Go preserves some student privacy.

Storing data in Google docs sends additional information to Google.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • Microsoft;
  • Google, twice (search and docs);
  • The school SIS (attendance, and possibly other class-related information).

D. English - Handing In A Paper

Services like TurnItIn.com rely on student Intellectual Property to run their service. A lawsuit in 2007 challenged this practice; TurnItIn prevailed in the case.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • TurnItIn.com (there are a slew of other options)
  • The school's SIS.

E. Lunch

Many schools manage their lunch programs using a Point of Sale vendor.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • The school's Point of Sale vendor - depending on the vendor, this information can be stored on or off site, but most solutions require some student information to track expenses to an individual.

F. Testing

In this example, Sondra's school (like many others) is piloting the Smarter Balanced tests. The example here could just as easily have been PARCC, NWEA, Pearson, or the College Board.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • The testing organization;
  • In some cases, question-level data is sent to the school's student information system;
  • In some cases, question-level data is sent to regional educational service entities.

G. Basketball Practice

That afternoon, during basketball practice, Sondra lands on the side of her foot after getting a rebound. Eventually, she's able to walk it off. Her coach is tracking types of injuries during specific drills, and he makes a note of Sondra's sprained ankle.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • Possibly, the school's SIS; and/or
  • Possibly, a third party coaching app.

H. Study Group

When Sondra is on her way to her study group, the geolocation on her iPad is tracking her movement. When she gets to her study group, her searches and the text of her research is being sent to Microsoft and Google, at the very least.

For this part of the day, data is sent to:

  • Apple, or whatever company is tracking iPad location;
  • Microsoft;
  • Google.

Defining Educational Records

FERPA defines "educational records", but various data streams described here don't fit neatly into the definitions within FERPA. As students progress through a single day, they create a data stream that can easily be spread across five or more service providers. Many of these providers offer no opportunity for students or parents to review or scrub a data trail.

In the example used here, Sondra is a public school student on a school-issued device. Do her parents have the right to examine Sondra's geolocation data (fwiw, Apple's track record here is pretty spotty)? In the example used here, accessing the geolocation data could potentially have personal repercussions for Sondra. If a student does work on a school provided device after hours, and that work is saved and stored in a place that is maintained by the school or an agent of the school, is that an "educational record"? What ownership do students, or their parents, have over the flow of data that arises when a kid has a normal day of school? Sondra is a public school student, using a school-provided device - how does that change the picture of student ownership of her data, and who could potentially have rights to access it? If she used a family-provided computer to access school provided services outside school hours to create something, who would have the ability to control when and how that was used?

In the course of a fairly typical day, Sondra created a data trail that is stored on the servers of at least 8 different vendors. Her school only has direct access to a subset of that data, and no one has delete rights over it. The activities looked at in this post intentionally left out Facebook and Instagram, and the ecosystem of apps that spread a person's data over a range of advertisers and sites. In this context, simple privacy isn't adequate. Sondra owns her life, and she should own the data that results from her life. From a pedogogical place, it only makes sense that students should be able to reflect on the data trails they create. From a "creating informed people in the 21st century" place, it only makes sense that people get the chance to see the full breadth of the data trails they create.

The laws around data in education have yet to catch up with the realities of data in education. One way to fill the gap, short term, is with effective policies at the school and district level.

Notes

* While "Sondra" is having a pretty typical school day, there is no actual person named "Sondra." She is a fictional invention meant to personalize the experiences many students have on a daily basis.

, , , ,

Some Pre-Session Thoughts On Creating And Using Open Content

2 min read

In preparing for my Educon session, I've spent a fair amount of time reviewing the existing open content repositories, as well as sites dedicated to sharing individual lessons. Leaving the licensing terms of some lesson sharing sites aside for the moment, this review showed that if you are looking for either a complete openly licensed text or an individual lesson, you will have plenty - really, an almost overwhelming amount - of options.

What's largely missing, though, are any comparable sites supporting the work of teachers looking to create and share coherent sets of resources and activities that can be used to support learning. In working on the details of the Ancient Civilizations project, I found myself creating exactly that: a set of resources that hold together as a unit, and inform the daily work within the class.

To put it another way, what we're aiming to create in this project is a toolkit that is much bigger than an individual lesson, and fits alongside a traditional text. Maybe it replaces the traditional text, maybe it doesn't, but really, that's not the point. Open content can chart a different path that is rooted in the daily experience of learners.

This is likely obvious to a lot of people, but I had never thought about it in this way prior to really digging into building this Ancient Civilizations toolkit. The middle ground - between a text and larger than an individual lesson - could be a sweet spot to help more people understand and use openly licensed resources.

, ,